Evidence & Source Register

The source trail behind the Project River case file.

Source type tells you who said it. It does not automatically tell you whether the claim is true.

Source hierarchy

For legal obligations, enacted laws, final ordinances, issued permits, and official agency records carry the most weight. For factual events, dated minutes, agendas, deeds, recordings, filings, and signed agreements are preferred. For engineering, complete technical reports with inputs and limitations are stronger than promotional summaries. For contested allegations, a filing proves that a claim was made; it does not prove the claim itself.

Technical review

PFPI analysis audited against stronger sources

PFPI’s Project River analysis is classified here as Third-Party Analysis. Its accessible quantitative claims were compared with developer statements, USDA, EIA, EPA, TDEC, and forestry-market evidence; its estimates remain analysis rather than project facts.

Government Statement
RIV-001

City of Cleveland — Project River meeting suspension / engineering review

City of Cleveland · 2026-09-18

The city’s original NewsFlash detail URL now returns 404, but the official Cleveland homepage continues to surface the announcement that direct Project River meetings were suspended while a third-party engineering review is pursued and that the Sept. 21 meeting was canceled.

Open source ↗
Government Statement
RIV-002

City of Cleveland — Lower River Road annexation page

City of Cleveland · 2026-09-26

As of Sept. 26, 2026, this city page listed a separate 385.58-acre Lower River Road request and a Sept. 28 hearing. The current landing page no longer displays those project-specific details; the final Sept. 28 City Council agenda is tracked separately as RIV-036.

Open source ↗
Government Statement
RIV-003

Cleveland 2024 Council Minutes — 9227 Frontage Road annexation

City of Cleveland · 2024

Documents the earlier 4.93-acre Frontage Road annexation proceeding. It does not by itself establish the intent or legal effect of later Project River annexation activity.

Open source ↗
Government Statement
RIV-004

Cleveland Planning Commission agenda — Sept. 16, 2025

City of Cleveland · 2025-09-16

Includes the Bacon/Bruner Frontage Road annexation matter referenced in the local boundary chronology.

Open source ↗
Government Statement
RIV-005

Bradley County Commission minutes — Dec. 15, 2025

Bradley County · 2025-12-15

Documents an interlocal agreement involving Bruner One LLC and a noncontiguous Frontage Road annexation.

Open source ↗
Government Statement
RIV-006

Tennessee Code § 6-51-104 — annexation

Tennessee Code / Justia statutory mirror · 2025 edition

Legal framework relevant to contiguous and qualifying noncontiguous annexation. Application to specific parcels requires parcel-level legal review.

Open source ↗
Government Statement
RIV-007

TDEC — Air public participation notices

Tennessee Department of Environment & Conservation · current

Use actual project-specific permit notices for filing status, comment deadlines, and hearings.

Open source ↗
Government Statement
RIV-008

TDEC — Water public participation notices

Tennessee Department of Environment & Conservation · current

Use actual project-specific permit notices for water, stormwater, discharge, and related comment opportunities.

Open source ↗
Government Statement
RIV-009

TDEC Chattanooga Environmental Field Office

Tennessee Department of Environment & Conservation · current

Regional contact point for routing air, water, waste, and other environmental questions.

Open source ↗
Government Statement
RIV-010

Tennessee Division of Forestry — forest resources

Tennessee Department of Agriculture · current

Useful source for forest inventory and utilization context when evaluating biomass-feedstock claims.

Open source ↗
Government Statement
RIV-011

TDOT Region 2 — traffic impact study contacts

Tennessee Department of Transportation · current

Relevant to traffic-impact studies, commercial access, and road-improvement questions.

Open source ↗
Government Statement
RIV-012

Tennessee Public Records Act FAQs

Tennessee Comptroller / Office of Open Records Counsel · current

Explains public-record response requirements and limitations.

Open source ↗
Developer Statement
RIV-013

Project River — The Project

Project River / Wright family project site · 2026-09

Current developer page describes four phases over 60 months, beginning with 250 MW of gas generation and reaching 1,500 MW onsite plus 360 MW of grid backup. It also describes water recovery, investment, forestry, jobs, and end-user categories; no offtake agreement is identified.

Open source ↗
Developer Statement
RIV-014

Project River — Wright Family Accepts Development Requirements

Project River · 2026-09-15

Developer description of proposed PUD 77 conditions. The page itself says finalization and passage are still required.

Open source ↗
Developer Statement
RIV-015

Project River — A New Tax Base for Cleveland and Bradley County

Project River · 2026-08-26

Developer claims about tax-base benefits and infrastructure cost allocation; detailed figures were not yet published on this page.

Open source ↗
Developer Statement
RIV-016

Project River — Newsroom

Project River · 2026-09

Project announcements, community-meeting notices, interviews, and project information.

Open source ↗
Developer Statement
RIV-017

Azure Engineering — Project River profile

Azure Engineering · 2026-09

Current Azure profile describes a 1,500 MW Tennessee project built in five phases, beginning with a 100 MW gas plant, plus 500 MW biomass and water-recovery / closed-loop claims. This phase description differs from the current Project River site and should be reconciled against the current design basis.

Open source ↗
Developer Statement
RIV-018

Algorhythm Holdings 8-K — Azure Energy acquisition

U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission · 2026-09-15

Primary filing confirming Algorhythm’s acquisition transaction involving Azure Energy and related entities.

Open source ↗
Developer Statement
RIV-019

Algorhythm acquisition press release

Algorhythm Holdings · 2026-09-15

Company statements about Azure backlog, project interests, technology, and collective team experience. Team experience should not be treated as Azure corporate operating history without project-by-project verification.

Open source ↗
Third-Party Analysis
RIV-020

Cleveland-Bradley Free Press — Project River public-record overview

Cleveland-Bradley Free Press · 2026-08-27

Local sourced reporting that compiles public records and project claims.

Open source ↗
Third-Party Analysis
RIV-021

Cleveland-Bradley Free Press — Sept. 1 community meeting

Cleveland-Bradley Free Press · 2026-09-01

Reports that the development team said no data-center operator contract had been signed and described annexation/PUD as necessary for the project path.

Open source ↗
Third-Party Analysis
RIV-022

Cleveland-Bradley Free Press — Sept. 12 community meeting

Cleveland-Bradley Free Press · 2026-09-12

Reports both supportive building-trades voices and widespread resident concerns at the second community meeting.

Open source ↗
Third-Party Analysis
RIV-023

Cleveland-Bradley Free Press — Project River reference page

Cleveland-Bradley Free Press · 2026-09-21

Living local chronology and source index. The current page reports that formal campus requests were withdrawn on Sept. 21. The official city Agenda Center confirms the Sept. 21 Planning Commission meeting was canceled; No corresponding primary withdrawal filing is included in the current source register, so the withdrawal claim remains attributed to this reporting.

Open source ↗
Third-Party Analysis
RIV-024

WCLE — Sept. 14 Cleveland City Council recap

Mix 104.1 WCLE · 2026-09-15

Reports city statements that the Sept. 21 event was intended for presentation rather than a vote and that further community meetings were expected.

Open source ↗
Third-Party Analysis
RIV-025

Steimle et al. v. Thompson — federal docket

U.S. District Court docket via Justia · 2024

Confirms a 2024 dispute involving Michael Steimle, Azure Holding Group LLC, and Andrew Thompson. A federal court remanded for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction; the docket is not a finding that the underlying allegations were true.

Open source ↗
Court Decision
RIV-026

Steimle v. Thompson — remand order

U.S. District Court order mirror · 2024-08-26

Shows the federal case was remanded to Wyoming Chancery Court for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction; it did not adjudicate the merits of the underlying dispute.

Open source ↗
Community Concern
RIV-027

Reject Project River public social-media archive

Community commentary · 2026-09

The public social-media archive shows recurring concerns about annexation, biomass scale, water, traffic, air emissions, noise, property effects, corporate experience, public process, and future project substitutions. Posts are evidence of community concerns, not proof of the underlying claims.

Archive held in the Placeward research set.
Third-Party Analysis
RIV-028

Southern Environmental Law Center — Sept. 18 Project River letter

Southern Environmental Law Center · 2026-09-18

Nine-page letter to Cleveland officials arguing against the proposed annexation and raising biomass, emissions, traffic, water, noise, and permitting concerns. These are SELC legal arguments and technical estimates, not court or agency findings.

Open source ↗
Placeward Analysis
RIV-029

Project River Community Reference & Action Plan v1.1

Placeward working synthesis / community research set · 2026-09-20

Structured synthesis of the evidence set, open questions, agencies, records requests, and 12 issue areas. It is a secondary working document; underlying primary sources control if there is a conflict.

Archive held in the Placeward research set.
Placeward Analysis
RIV-030

Project River Community Action & Evidence Tracker v1.2

Placeward working tracker / community research set · 2026-09-20

Tracks actions, record requests, studies, open issues, source links, contributor verification, and alternative project scenarios. It is not a live government calendar.

Archive held in the Placeward research set.
Community Concern
RIV-031

East Tennessee / Tennessee Data Center Principles & Action Agenda

Community policy document · 2026-09-26

Records community principles and requested reforms, including transparency, fair cost allocation, property/community protection, independent review, enforceable commitments, review of material project changes, and long-term accountability. These are policy positions, not factual findings about Project River.

Archive held in the Placeward research set.
Government Statement
RIV-032

Cleveland Planning Commission Agenda Center

City of Cleveland · 2026-09-26

Official agenda index labels the Sept. 21, 2026 special-called Planning Commission meeting CANCELED.

Open source ↗
Government Statement
RIV-033

Tennessee Code § 6-58-118 — limited Urban Growth Boundary expansion

Tennessee Code / Justia statutory mirror · 2025 edition

Statutory criteria for a municipality to expand its Urban Growth Boundary for a tract without reconvening the coordinating committee or obtaining county approval.

Open source ↗
Third-Party Analysis
RIV-034

MTAS — Tennessee annexation overview

University of Tennessee Municipal Technical Advisory Service · 2026-01-05

Technical guidance summarizing Tennessee annexation methods, Urban Growth Boundary requirements, non-contiguous annexation, plans of service, and related statutory provisions. It is guidance, not a substitute for the statutory text or legal advice.

Open source ↗
Government Statement
RIV-035

Cleveland 2025 Council Minutes — March 2025 Growth Plan

City of Cleveland · 2025-03-24

Resolution 2025-26 ratifies the amended Twenty-Year Growth Plan for Charleston/Cleveland/Bradley County, including an expansion of Cleveland’s Urban Growth Boundary.

Open source ↗
Government Statement
RIV-036

Cleveland City Council agenda — Sept. 28, 2026

City of Cleveland · 2026-09-28

Final Sept. 28 City Council agenda. The previously noticed 385.58-acre Lower River Road Wright Brothers annexation request does not appear among the listed public hearings or business items.

Open source ↗
Developer Statement
RIV-037

Project River — Local Benefits

Project River · 2026-09

Developer page giving the current employment breakdown: 900 permanent direct jobs (250 power generation, 525 data center, 125 biomass handling/processing), about 1,700 indirect forestry jobs, and roughly 3,500 workers at peak construction. These are project forecasts, not realized employment.

Open source ↗
Third-Party Analysis
RIV-038

Partnership for Policy Integrity — Project River resource-use and pollution analysis

Partnership for Policy Integrity (PFPI) · 2026-09-30

Third-party technical/advocacy analysis focused on the proposed 500 MW biomass component. PFPI states that it works to oppose forest biomass and support groups challenging biomass projects. This page is useful for technical hypotheses and source discovery, not as a primary authority; calculations and conclusions are checked against underlying records and independent data where possible.

Open source ↗
Third-Party Analysis
RIV-039

Chattanooga Times Free Press — Sept. 1 Project River community meeting

Chattanooga Times Free Press · 2026-09-01

Reports developer statements at the Sept. 1 meeting that the proposed 500 MW biomass plant would consume about 5.5 million tons of timber annually and require roughly 380–500 truckloads of logs per day if supplied by truck. The article also reports that developers described the plant as far larger than existing U.S. woody-biomass plants.

Open source ↗
Government Statement
RIV-040

USDA Forest Service — Timber Product Output and Use for Tennessee, 2024

U.S. Department of Agriculture, Forest Service · 2026-02

Statewide Timber Product Output benchmark based on surveys of primary wood-processing facilities. Useful for Tennessee timber-use context, but it is not a Project River-specific 200-mile procurement study and does not by itself establish how much feedstock is economically or sustainably available to the project.

Open source ↗
Government Statement
RIV-041

EIA Electric Power Annual — wood and wood-derived fuel generation, 2024

U.S. Energy Information Administration · 2025-10-16

EIA Table 3.1.B reports 31,564 thousand MWh of U.S. electricity generation from wood and wood-derived fuels in 2024. This provides a national scale benchmark; it does not predict Project River output or operating capacity factor.

Open source ↗
Government Statement
RIV-042

EIA Electric Power Annual — wood/wood-waste biomass consumption for electricity generation, 2024

U.S. Energy Information Administration · 2025-10-16

EIA Table 5.5.D reports 279,132 billion Btu of U.S. wood/wood-waste biomass consumption for electricity generation in 2024. It is a national benchmark and should not be converted into a Project River fuel-tonnage estimate without River-specific fuel moisture, heating value, efficiency, and operating assumptions.

Open source ↗
Government Statement
RIV-043

EPA AP-42 Section 1.6 — Wood Residue Combustion in Boilers

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency · 2022-04

EPA emissions-factor reference for wood-residue combustion in boilers. It can be used for screening and comparison when the process is applicable, but it is not a substitute for Project River-specific process design, fuel specification, controls, stack parameters, permit calculations, and dispersion modeling.

Open source ↗
Government Statement
RIV-044

TDEC — Posted Streams, Rivers & Reservoirs fish-advisory list

Tennessee Department of Environment & Conservation · 2025-04

The April 2025 list identifies a Hiwassee River segment spanning Meigs, McMinn, and Bradley counties with a precautionary largemouth-bass advisory for mercury. This documents a specific existing water-quality concern; it does not establish a national ranking of the Hiwassee as one of the country’s most polluted watersheds.

Open source ↗
Third-Party Analysis
RIV-045

Forisk — U.S. Southeast Wood Fiber Market Updates

Forisk Consulting · 2025-09-30

Regional wood-fiber market analysis documenting major Southeast mill closures and reduced wood demand, including 4.6 million tons of demand removed by specified 2025 Georgia closures. Useful market context, but not a Project River-specific procurement analysis.

Open source ↗
Third-Party Analysis
RIV-046

Forisk — Biomass Prices Continue to Decline in the U.S. South

Forisk Consulting · 2026-03-24

Reports declining Southeast biomass prices and a current surplus of some feedstock, attributed in part to lingering storm-damaged timber and weak residual markets. This supports the existence of near-term surplus conditions in parts of the Southeast, but not a conclusion that 5–7 million tons per year are durably available to Project River without competition or ecological effects.

Open source ↗
Third-Party Analysis
RIV-047

Chattanooga Times Free Press — Aug. 26 Project River proposal overview

Chattanooga Times Free Press · 2026-08-26

Early Project River reporting attributes an estimate of about 5 million tons of timber annually at full operations to the developers. Later developer/public figures increased to about 5.5 million tons at the Sept. 1 meeting and 6 million tons on the current Project River site.

Open source ↗